Opposition to Proposed Ban on Private Practice by Government Doctors in Bihar
Concerns Raised by Bihar Health Services Association
Patna: The Bihar Health Services Association (BHSA) has voiced strong opposition to the Bihar government’s proposed ban on private practice for government doctors. BHSA leaders argue that such a policy should only be considered after addressing the systemic deficiencies plaguing public healthcare institutions.
Call for Infrastructure Improvements
During a meeting at the Indian Medical Association (IMA) hall, BHSA representatives highlighted that implementing a blanket ban on private practice would be unjust and impractical without the necessary infrastructure, functional medical equipment, and adequate staffing in government hospitals. The association emphasized that enhancements in working conditions, staffing levels for doctors, nurses, and paramedical personnel, along with meaningful professional incentives, are essential prerequisites for any reform.
Financial Considerations for Doctors
According to Hindustan Times, BHSA spokesperson Dr. Vinay Kumar stated that private practice cannot be arbitrarily prohibited. He further noted that if the government intends to enforce such a ban, it must provide a reasonable non-practice allowance (NPA) or a financial compensation framework to mitigate the income loss experienced by doctors.
Potential Impact on Patient Care
BHSA leaders warned that enforcing a ban without considering the realities on the ground could have negative repercussions for patient care, especially for economically disadvantaged groups. They cautioned that this move might lead to the dominance of large private multi-specialty hospitals, thereby limiting access to affordable healthcare. The association vowed to oppose the proposal in the interest of patients and the public health system.
Formal Submission of Concerns
The BHSA also resolved to formally present its concerns and demands to the state health department. On January 27, the Bihar health department established a six-member committee tasked with consulting stakeholders regarding the proposed ban on private practice by government doctors and exploring incentives for those serving in remote and rural areas. This committee is chaired by Dr. Rekha Jha, Director-in-Chief (Nursing and Disease Control), Bihar Health Services.
Context of the Proposed Ban
This proposal is part of the fifth resolution—“accessible health-secure life”—under the state government’s flagship program, Saat Nischay-3 (Seven Resolves 3.0), aimed at the 2025–2030 period. The policy framework seeks to prohibit private practice while introducing a dedicated incentive structure to enhance healthcare delivery in underserved rural and remote regions.
Key BHSA Leaders Present at the Meeting
Prominent BHSA office-bearers attending the meeting included President Dr. KK Mani, General Secretary Dr. Rohit Kumar, Finance Secretary-cum-Office Secretary Dr. Kumar Saurabh, and Patron Dr. Ranjit Kumar.