Effectiveness of DIY Face Masks Compared to Surgical Masks

Introduction to Mask Efficacy

Researchers have conducted a study comparing various DIY face masks to surgical masks to evaluate their effectiveness in minimizing droplet dispersal from the nose and mouth. The SARS-CoV-2 virus, responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic, spreads primarily through droplets released by infected individuals during activities such as speaking, coughing, and sneezing. Face masks play a crucial role in reducing the transmission of viral droplets from those who are infected and may also offer protection to healthy individuals from inhaling these droplets.

Public Health Recommendations for Face Coverings

In light of the pandemic and the necessity to preserve medical-grade masks for healthcare professionals, public health organizations like the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in the United States have recommended that the general public utilize cloth DIY face masks. Various materials and designs for these masks have been proposed, yet evidence concerning their effectiveness remains limited.

Research Study on Mask Types

Study Overview

Researchers at the University of New South Wales in Australia conducted a video case study to analyze the performance of different DIY face masks in comparison to surgical masks. Their findings were recently published in the journal Thorax.

Mask Types Tested

The study involved a healthy volunteer who was tested wearing a three-ply surgical mask, as well as single-layer and double-layer cotton cloth DIY masks. The single-layer mask was created using a “quick-cut T-shirt no-sew” method, while the double-layer mask adhered to the sewing method recommended by the CDC. The researchers employed an LED lighting system and a high-speed camera to assess droplet expulsion during speaking, coughing, and sneezing.

Findings on Droplet Spread

The results indicated that the surgical mask was the most effective in reducing droplet dispersion during all activities assessed. Additionally, the double-layer cloth DIY mask outperformed the single-layer version in minimizing droplet spread, although the single-layer mask still provided some benefits.

Recommendations for DIY Mask Use

Importance of Layering

This study highlights the significance of face masks and the variances among different types. Although it represents a single case study, the researchers advise that DIY mask instructions should recommend using multiple layers of fabric, ideally at least three layers, for individuals who can wear a mask.

CDC Guidelines on Mask Usage

The CDC states that “cloth face coverings should NOT be worn by children under the age of 2 or anyone who has trouble breathing, is unconscious, incapacitated, or otherwise unable to remove the mask without assistance.” Furthermore, the study authors note that several factors influence the effectiveness of DIY masks, including the material used, the design and fit of the masks, and how frequently they are washed. They emphasize the necessity for additional research to enhance DIY mask design and functionality.

Conclusion

The research underscores the role of face masks in curbing the spread of COVID-19 and highlights the need for further exploration into the optimal design and use of DIY masks.

References

1. Bahl P, Bhattacharjee S, de Silva C, et al. Face coverings and mask to minimize droplet dispersion and aerosolisation: a video case study. Thorax Published Online First: July 24, 2020. doi:10.1136/thoraxjnl-2020-215748
2. BMJ Press Release, 23 July 2020. Home-made face masks likely need at least 2 layers to curb COVID-19 spread. https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2020-07/b-hfm072220.php

Image by Lukáš Jančička from Pixabay