Debate on Obesity Classification in Healthcare

Overview of the Discussion

Recently, three notable healthcare providers engaged in a debate regarding the classification of obesity as a disease, featured in BMJ Today. The issue of obesity is becoming increasingly prevalent in developed nations, leading to various health complications, including high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes, and hormone-dependent cancers. The World Health Organization has categorized obesity as a disease since 1936. While both the Canadian Medical Association and the American Medical Association now recognize obesity as a disease, this classification has not yet been adopted in the UK.

Arguments for Classifying Obesity as a Disease

During the discussion, a university professor and a representative from the European Coalition for People Living with Obesity presented arguments supporting the classification of obesity as a disease. They contend that the accumulation of body fat can significantly impact health, and the rapid increase in obesity rates in the UK is largely influenced by environmental factors, including food availability, cost, physical surroundings, and social influences. This perspective challenges the societal notion that obesity is solely a personal choice, suggesting instead that it may be beyond individual control. They argue that recognizing obesity as a disease could help reduce the stigma and discrimination faced by many individuals with obesity.

Counterarguments Against the Disease Classification

Conversely, a general practice doctor from the UK expressed concerns that labeling obesity as a disease could disempower individuals, diminishing their sense of control over their health. He emphasized the psychological difference between viewing obesity as a manageable risk factor versus a disease requiring external treatment. According to him, defining obesity as a disease could undermine the intrinsic motivation that drives individuals to make positive changes in their lifestyles. He also raised concerns that such a classification could lead to health insurers and clinical guidelines favoring pharmaceutical interventions and surgical options, benefiting the pharmaceutical industry and healthcare providers.

Conclusion on the Classification of Obesity

Ultimately, the debate about whether to classify obesity as a disease is complex and fraught with implications. The discussion highlights the need for careful consideration of the potential risks and benefits associated with such a classification.

References

1. Should Obesity Be Recognised as a Disease. BMJ 2019;366:l4258
2. Should obesity be recognized as a disease? EurekAlert! https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2019-07/b-sob071519.php Last accessed July 19, 2019.

Image Credit

Image by Vidmir Raic from Pixabay